Outlander 207: (You Gotta Have) Faith

Okay, friends. Fortitude. We’re going to get through this one together. (Even though as I sit down to watch it, I’m already crying.) Let’s do it.

Oh, right—um, SPOILER ALERT, SPOILER ALERT. Watch episode 207, “Faith,” before reading this. (Then watch it again when you can hear the dialog over your own crying.)

First off, hats off to writer Toni Graphia, who had a monster job to do with this thing, and pulled it off in the most gorgeous, honest, and devastating way. I mean, let’s think about this for a second—this is the last France episode. So not only do we have to get through all the aftermath of the “Faith” stuff, but we have to sum up all the story arcs of everyone we’ve met in France and get our main characters back to Scotland while we do it. And in only, what? 60 minutes? Bravo, Toni!

As Toni says in the commentary, this episode is called “Faith,” not only because it’s the name of Claire and Jamie’s stillborn child, but because it is the theme. “They haven’t lost faith in each other,” she explains. In fact, you might say, Faith is the theme of the whole damn book, while you’re at it.

Now I talk in depth about all this in my article Outlander 2: Liberté, Égalité et Faith, in case you haven’t read it yet.

But for now, let’s talk about our opening image:

2016-05-21 17.12.36
Boston 1954

Now of course, we know that Claire is pregnant when she goes back through the stones to Frank in episode 201, but actually seeing her here with this little redheaded girl is completely toying with us. Who is this girl? Is this the baby she was carrying all season? Is everything actually going to be okay with this pregnancy? (And those of us who have read the books know the answer, but still– hope is born.)

And as the beautiful heron soars through the sky, taking us back to France, we get our answer.

No. Everything is not okay.

And now we see Claire lying in the hospital, with Mother Hildegarde hovering over her:

2016-05-21 17.16.13
“Be still, my child. I am here. We will take care of you.”

The whispered prayers, the chaos. “I am here,” says Mother Hildegarde.

“Jamie” is all Claire can whisper. Blood all over the sheets. Listless and scared, Claire is drifting through this experience as in a dream. Her helplessness is devastating.

She feels her stomach. It is empty. “Where’s my baby?”

“I am sorry, madame. She has joined the angels.”

It is not a coincidence, of course, that this hospital is called L’Hopital d’Anges – Hospital of the Angels. Claire is surrounded by her ghosts.

“I baptized her and gave her a name. Faith,” says Mother Hildegarde. Illegal to do so with a stillborn baby. But that way she could be buried in the church cemetery.

2016-05-21 17.14.43
“This will stay between you, me, and God.”

And when the priest asks Claire if she has any sins to confess, she answers, quite honestly, “My sins are all I have left.”

The last rites are performed, and you see the look in her eyes, wondering if she even has the strength to keep fighting. Bouton guards her through the night as she trembles.

And in walks a cloaked figure, speaking French. “Be still now. Hush, Madonna. If they find me here, I’m finished.” It is Raymond.

And just as in the novel, Claire is brought back from the brink of death by his healing hands. She surely would have died of the infection otherwise. She looks up to the blue wings of the flying bird.

2016-05-21 17.20.12

The placenta is festering, the bacteria inhabiting the blood.

“Call him. Call to him,” demands Raymond.

2016-05-21 17.21.17
“No, Jamie!”

“Be well, Madonna,” says Raymond, who is escaping from the king’s witch hunt and may never see Claire again. “I am no Madonna,” she explains. “I have no child.” And Raymond explains quite beautifully that he doesn’t call her Madonna because she has a child, but because her aura is blue, like the Virgin’s cloak.

“We will see each other again,” he tells her. “Have faith.”

Claire discovers that Jamie is in the Bastille for dueling, but because he didn’t actually kill Jack, the punishment is not as bad as it could have been. Oh good, it’s been a few months since Jamie was in prison for something. (Seriously, is it just me, or is Jamie in prison, like, every other month? Guess they didn’t have a lot of three strikes laws in 18th century France.)

Black Jack Randall has gone back to England, so we’ll just stick him on a back burner for a while, and focus and Claire’s hostility towards Jamie for fighting him in the first place: “Revenge mattered more to him than me, or his child… He may as well have run his sword through me.”


2016-05-21 17.17.53
“Tread sins underfoot and hurl inequities into the sea.”

“I’m not sure there’s a sea deep enough,” Claire responds. (Again, Toni Graphia—you’re slaying me here.)

So let’s cut to a few weeks later:

2016-05-21 17.24.20
“My body had healed, my soul had not.”

Magnus and the other staff welcome her home. I know some people are put off by the familiarity between the staff and the aristocracy (in this case, Jamie and Claire), which—true—is not very historically accurate. But it really adds something to their home scenes which would be quite cold otherwise.

Fergus brushes her hair and sees the perfume bottles.

2016-05-21 17.24.45

“What is it?” Claire asks, when she sees him shudder. “No—nothing, m’lady.”

Remember that at this point, Claire has no idea why Jamie decided to duel Jack early, instead of keeping his promise to wait a year. But after hurling the christening spoons under the bed and pacing the hallways, crying and lost, Claire hears Fergus in his bedroom:

“Stop! S’il vous plait!” he shouts.

And he finally explains to her what we may have already guessed from last week: Fergus was raped by Black Jack Randall that day in the brothel, and Jamie walked in on them.

And so we see why Jamie demanded the duel immediately.

2016-05-21 17.27.37“Now my lord is gone. He will never come back,” worries Fergus. Well, not if Claire has anything to do with it! With a new mission in life, Claire throws on the 18th century version of the bandage dress and goes to see Hildegarde, inquiring about a private audience with the king.

Claire “has found a deep enough sea.”

2016-05-21 17.28.03
“When it comes to sacrificing my virtue, Mother, I will add it to the list of things I have already lost in Paris.”

So, on to the B story—I mean, the king’s palace. Claire strolls down this elegant but tasteful corridor that looks like it was designed by Skeletor and goes to see the king of hand gestures.


So we sit down with the king, have some churros y chocolate, some creepy looking oranges. Oh, this is going well. If you don’t count the fact that there’s an absurdly large bed in the foreground of this little meeting, portending some kinky shit that’s about to go down. I will say this: nice of the show to cast a handsome man as the king, instead of the weird smelly hedgehog I was picturing in the book.

2016-05-21 17.31.04

PS: The thought of having sex just weeks after a miscarriage—just ew. And ow. And ew again.

Anyway, let’s move on. Claire lets the king know that she is “entirely at his disposal,” the innuendo practically dripping off her tongue. And then he takes her hand, noting the two wedding rings:

2016-05-21 17.30.51
“Your loyalty is most noteworthy.”

But as it turns out, the king is going to want more than just the obligatory “sex toll,” if you will. La Dame Blanche, after all, is known for other talents. And it’s high time she starts using them.

So off we go to…

2016-05-21 17.33.25

Eyes Wide Shut… I mean, the Bridge of the Battlestar Galactica—wait, where are we again, Ron Moore? Ah, still in France, not in space (or a Kubrick movie). This is just a really awesome star room/place to torture people to death.

And while we’re going full Kubrick with the weirdness here, let’s visit with our favorite ob/gyn from hell: Monsieur Forez.

“His presence could mean only one thing,” Claire realizes. “There would be death here today.”

2016-05-21 17.34.28

And whom might we have the pleasure of torturing to death this day? Why, it’s our old friends, Master Raymond and the Comte St. Germain.

2016-05-21 17.35.47
“Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ.”

The king makes his intentions clear: “Look into their souls, and if there is darkness within, they will be handed over to M. Forez and put to death.”

Oh, Claire, can’t a girl just sleep with the king of France to set her husband free from the Bastille in peace anymore? Why do things always have to get so complicated?

And here Claire, who knows what role she’s expected to play in this scene, really turns up the juice. Playing up a delicious pantomime of lusty witchery, she turns to the comte.

2016-05-21 17.38.06
“I see a shadow behind your eyes, comte.”

She accuses him, in front of the king, of being the mastermind of the rape of Mary, and the brains behind Les Disciples. He denies it, of course, but his fate is already sealed. Claire, however, still thinks she can maneuver the pieces of this chess set to her liking. Dismissing the (super creepy) snake, who blissfully stays in his cage, she concocts a plan to “poison” both men with bitter cascara, thereby setting them both free.

2016-05-21 17.39.14
“Without darkness, there can be no light.”

But there’s a little knowing look in Raymond’s eyes. This opportunity isn’t going to slip through his fingers. He drinks the potion, “doubles over in pain,” and slips something into the cup before the comte drinks it.

And here’s where this episode goes from just really good to pretty friggin’ genius—the “I only turn black in the presence of poison” necklace that Claire has had dangling from her delicate white neck ever since Raymond gave it to her… well, it does this:

2016-05-21 17.41.08

And no one is more surprised than she is. But she knows what it means. And so does the comte.

And even as he spits a line like this at our heroine before drinking it…

2016-05-21 17.42.16

…I still get a little lump in my throat as tears escape from his Paul Newman blue eyes and he knows he’s going to die. Sorry, I’m really shallow. I get sad when cute men die.

So I think our work in this scene is done. Raymond is free, the comte is dead, and Claire thinks she might be done for the day.

2016-05-21 17.42.58
“I’m going to miss you most of all… Toto.”

But of course, there’s just one more little obligation before Jamie is to be set free:

2016-05-21 17.43.57
“I closed my eyes… and thought of England.”

Possibly the best line in the history of Outlander right there. (Apparently, this is something British moms used to tell their daughters on their wedding nights, to convince them that they would have to grin and bear the sex in order to procreate. Using it here is pure gold.) *Note, 5/22: I’m now getting word from a commentator that Queen Victoria herself dispensed this advice, since she never liked sex. Classic.

And how genius is it, by the way, of director Metin Hüseyin to parallel the shot of Claire in the hospital earlier with this one here? Sister can’t seem to get off her back in this episode.

So Two Pump Chump finishes up and Claire leaves. But first, she takes the orange. Classic.

And now we fade to BLACK.

What will come next? Freedom? Jamie? Scotland? Our Claire has had a hell of time of it lately, and she’s going to have decide what she wants. But first…

2016-05-21 17.45.59

Here comes our reluctant hero—climbing the stairs of his house like a condemned man climbing the gallows.

2016-05-21 17.51.46
“I don’t even know if it was a boy… or a girl.”

This line, also in the book, is the beginning of one of the most amazing scenes in this whole show. In Dragonfly in Amber, the process of Claire and Jamie reuniting, forgiving each other for their transgressions, accepting the mutual blame for the death of Faith, accepting that Claire slept with the king in order to release Jamie—all of this, and it’s a lot—takes quite a while. It’s a series of many scenes, slowly unraveling as they make their way back to Scotland. (I also talk about Claire’s confession to Jamie in my article on top-five Dragonfly moments, Outlander 2: Written in Diana’s Own Heart’s Blood.)

Here it’s one scene.

And what a scene it is, beautifully and heartbreakingly unraveling the thin threads of regret and forgiveness that hold together a marriage. Claire’s admission that she blames herself for Faith’s death is nothing short of devastating. Is she right? Should she have stayed in bed? Could there have been another outcome? She will never know.

2016-05-21 17.46.32
“It was a girl. Mother Hildegarde… gave her a name– Faith. Mother Hildegarde has a very odd sense of humor.”

And the clock ticks… louder, louder, taking us back into flashback. Another brilliant choice here, to save this most intimate and painful moment of Claire’s stay in the hospital for now, when Jamie is with her, as though he was living through it with her.

“Do you hate me for it, Claire?” he asks her.

“I did hate you,” she admits. And she takes him through her grief, like a painter detailing every stroke of her work.

Claire in the hospital bed with the little dead baby: “I could cup her head in the palm of my hand.” This description of the little body, as in the book, is so visceral, it’s almost a medical account. Jamie will have to know every moment of her despair, in order to truly be with her for their mutual recovery.

2016-05-21 17.47.50
“Oh, I do like to be beside the seaside. Oh, I do like to be beside the sea.”

I love that, in the commentary, Toni Graphia mentions that there was originally voiceover explaining why Claire sings this particular song—how her mother sang it to her. But when she saw Caitriona playing it– simple, honest, her grief pouring out into the words– she realized she didn’t need it. It’s a great lesson in writing: often, less is more.

2016-05-21 17.48.38And now we see Louise, possibly for the last time. And I love that she is the one to come to the bedside, her own pregnancy now beginning to show, as she takes the small baby from Claire’s arms to hand her to Mother Hildegarde. If it is the last time we see this character, then what a perfect way to close her arc, by letting her be the friend to begin Claire on her journey towards letting go.

“She’s an angel,” Louise says. And it’s true. In the “Hospital of Angels,” another spirit left behind.

2016-05-21 17.49.15
“So yes… I hated you.”

“But it was me who asked the impossible of you… me who put Frank before our family… me who followed you to the woods,” she continues, realizing that this time, she can’t blame Jack Randall or anyone else.

Claire will have to learn to forgive herself for all the things she has done wrong, all the mistakes, if she is ever going to heal. As for Jamie, he tells her: “I already forgave you, long before today, for this and anything else you could ever do.”

“How can we ever be the same?” she asks Jamie. And his simple response: “We can’t be.”

2016-05-21 17.52.01
“The only way we can live with it is to carry it… We lost our child, but by the grace of God, we may be given another.”

And that is when Claire realizes it is time to give up this futile effort in France. They’ve done all they can to derail Charles’ attempts to invade England. And it has cost them everything they had.

“Then bring me home,” Claire says, “to Scotland.”

“Aye, Scotland,” Jamie says, the first sincere smile he’s had for a while cracking across his tired face.

And there’s only one thing left to do:

2016-05-21 17.53.17
“If we must bury you here in France, let’s leave a bit of Scotland wi’ ya.”

Claire reaches out for Jamie’s hand… and he takes it. Fade to black.

Interested in reading more about Outlander? Check out all the articles under the “Outlander” tag on our home page: Novel2Screen.net

Follow Rebecca Phelps on Twitter @DownWorldNovel or “like” us on Facebook at Novel2Screen for more on your favorite novel-to-screen adaptations. Coming up next, JoJo Moyes’ Me Before You!

Or just follow this blog. 🙂 




7 thoughts on “Outlander 207: (You Gotta Have) Faith

  1. Even in the midst of this terrifying and sad episode, you just made me chuckle here. I love reading your assessments!


  2. Great recap. I love that after all the hoopla the past few weeks along the interwebs over Claire’s perceived recklessness, obsessiveness, controlingness, and general busybody-ness outside the scope of the primary objective, there’s vindication in that the cumulative effect of all her decisions comes back as the reality that her actions were as much responsible for their outcome as Jamie’s getting sidetracked with BJR.
    ….By the time she recounts her miscarriage to Jamie, and her own failings to herself, I’m wondering if in her mind she actually sees their mission as complete, tho at a huge price. For when last we saw the Bonnie Prince, it was understood that his goals remained unfruitful and had no choice but to return to Italy. At the point when she asks Jamie to take her home, I read it more as they feel there’s nothing left to do in France rather than the realization that their mission had failed. It seems more like they choose to go home because they feel it’s now safe, and time, to do so to go with their lives and work past their grief. Of course they will be accosted by political machinations beyond their control once more, that will yet again force them into action.
    The Bree tease I thought to be unnecessary, but it did serve to give the viewer reassurance, and a reminder before plunging in, that after this heartwrenching episode of despair is over, a new life will be created. And I guess if one reads into it enough, you get the message that her survival will be assured at all costs.
    The depiction of Fergus’s growing affection and loyalty to Milord on screen is moving to see unfold as well.


  3. Thanks for great recap. I also loved the positioning of the scene with Faith. Reflecting back, similar to how Jamie’s rape scenes were shown. Both having to re-tell horrific pain. Sharing the Claire/Faith scene in the same way was directing, eduting, writing (whomever mad the decision) brilliance.


  4. Love how you write. Love how you “get it.” Even though I knew the outcome. Even though I know what is to come, I look forward to reading your take on the pivotal happening in “Voyager.” Season 3 is a must.


  5. You’re review of this episode is spot on. I actually started crying again just reading your recap. I have read through Voyager and am currently on Drums of Autumn. The way they managed to wrap up all these storylines in 60 minutes was amazing. The acting was phenomenal as always, the pain and heartbreak of both Jamie and Claire executed perfectly. Anyone who has lost a baby knows exactly how these two are feeling. I’m looking forward and dreading their return to Scotland, because all of us book readers know exactly what is to come. Keep up the great work and I will be waiting for next weeks review.


  6. Great review except the line “I’m going to miss you most of all” was referring to the Scarecrow, not Toto. Brilliant episode!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s